亨利(加里·格兰特 Cary Grant 饰)是一名英俊帅气的法国军官,在前线,他结识了前来应援的美国陆军妇女队军官凯瑟琳(安·谢里登 Ann Sheridan 饰),尽管两人之间的交流经常伴随着吵吵闹闹,但随着时间的推移,亦产生了真挚而奇妙的感情。
战争结束后,亨利决定跟随凯瑟琳前往美国,结婚并开始幸福的生活,然而此时,一个难题却摆在了他们的面前,那就是亨利并不能取得美国的合法居留权。为了解决这个问题,亨利和凯瑟琳想了一个损招,那就是让亨利打扮成妇女队的军官,混进美国。让两人没有想到的是,这个看似完美的计划执行起来却遭到了诸多变故,他们能够获得最终的“胜利”吗?
A post-WWII Howard Hawks screwball comedy transpires in the Allied-occupied Germany, Cary Grant plays a French Army Captain Henri Rochard, who is teamed up with American Lieutenant Catherine Gates (Sheridan) in his last mission before bowing out of military service once and for all.
It starts as a typical ill-matched pair reluctantly bundled together (even sharing the same bed one evening), who are constantly at each other’s throatsthrough comedy of errors, more often than not, at Henry’s expense, but, improbable to audience, a budding romantic is bound to emerge from both sides and by the end of their task, they are going to tie the knot. Honestly, the first half is very pleasurable with Grant adopts his tried-and-tested winning formula to juggle goofy, loosey-goosey innocuousness with snit-driven prolixity, meanwhile a proactive Ann Sheridan pulls no punch to prove that as a woman, her Catherine is no lesser to any masculine peer of hers, she can operate a spanking vehicle as competent as fast-tracking their mission.
In truth, it is this conformity-defying, role-swapping gender politics that gingers up the film right out of the box, however, in the second half, when the narrative is mired in overwrought red tapes, only to put the newly weds in the quagmire of a repeatedly deferred marriage consummation, and laboriously plays up the same source of amusement that Henri must apply as a war bride in order to be emigrated to USA as Catherine’s spouse, the film’s allure starts to pall, and its objectionable ethnocentric overtone doesn’t help either. When the plot reaches that mane-clipping, nurse-impersonating climax, it only leaves a first-time viewer gobsmacked, not by the plan’s wits but the whole idiocy which Hawks condones, maxing out Cary Grant’s belabored discomfiture but largely relegating Ann Sheridan on the sideline, an utter betrayal to its promising premise.
Another Golden Age Hollywood crowdpleaser doesn’t come through the test of time, as at one point Henri jests that woman is, au contraire, not the weaker gender to man since they are blessed with more sleep, the joke is in fact on the film and Hawks himself, a blatant tokenism in addressing gender equality, but cranked out inside a masculine hothouse, it is the same old blarney that now borders on offense.
referential films: Hawks’ BALL OF FIRE (1941, 7.5/10), BRINGING UP BABY (1938, 7.4/10), Billy Wilder’s A FOREIGN AFFAIR (1948, 6.8/10),
早年看到加利格兰特的造型时以为这电影很雷,但其实尺度并不大。人物对话有意思,其他时候趣味一般。
还好吧,Grant演法国人没有说服力,Ann戏份太少,而且跟男主也没火花= = 性别互换让男性体会女性艰辛倒还挺有意思(虽然男主角色性格很讨厌)。Grant的女装真的有丑到。
同样是变装喜剧,和比利怀德德剧本真是差了十万八千里,化学反应莫名其妙,笑点也寥寥,格兰特喜剧天赋太欠缺,扮女人更是谁也骗不过啊。
和[育婴奇谈]一个调,没那个疯,一样好笑!
在霍克斯喜剧中不算那么有名,笑点也不密集,主要看点是女装大佬格兰特,虽说低俗了点。影片整体调调倒是让人看的很轻松
前面好多精巧的斗嘴和slapstick,后半段进入正题却枯燥了
在小旅馆的部分是在致敬春闺风月 The Awful Truth (1937)吧。。。这部电影如果和柏林艳史一起观看会别有一番乐趣。。。霍克斯再一次恶搞性别互换但是剧本写的不理想,谢里登和格兰特也没啥化学反应,而且所有的噱头都用在了格兰特身上她根本没有表现的机会。。。
比《热情如火》更先锋吧,因为它真正地挑战了男性气质,还有不少卡夫卡式的笑料,比美国黑色幽默文学还要早很多。
这种deadpan调子不错,一切都顺理成章可又确实很好笑。男主实在太好欺负哈哈哈。
Cary Grant都被玩坏啦哈哈哈哈
2022.12.11 12:00 密集的笑点,如此窘迫的加里格兰特还真有点让人心疼。
Scénario peu ficelé, dialogues plats, cette screwball comedy poursuit la thématique chère à Hawk - rapport masculin-féminin marqué ici par l’inversion des rôles dominé et dominant jusqu’au travestissement de l’homme,qui reste le seul gag drôle de ce film mineur.
男扮女装纯粹为噱头,和霍克斯以往的喜剧相比这部平庸得多~
本片又名《折腾不死加里格兰特就把帅哥往丑里搞》...
这部有点乱糟糟,加里·格兰特怎么都不象个法国人,你看人家虎口脱险里油漆粉刷工都不知高出了多少。
"I am an alien spouse of female military personnel en route to the United States under public law 271 of the congress."
影片实在好笑,都是通过格兰特的大男子形象惨遭损毁来实现,门把手坏了,又不敢同床,蜷在椅子上姿势用尽,边三轮无人驾驶,径直钻入草垛,新婚夜睡浴缸,假扮新娘无处歇宿,窝囊到这个份儿上,还要顶着马尾蒙混上船,真是让人同情。
有些《育婴奇谭》的味道 前半程笑料集中 后面淡了 格兰特都被玩坏了最后的女装实在是太坏了啊哈哈哈哈
经典老电影。
前半段比后半段更好笑,Grant到了Hawks的镜头里就成了人人都要欺负一把的可怜娃。