Other than being a sartorial trendsetter of its namesake Kitty Foyle dress, Sam Wood’s solid screen adaptation of Christopher Morley’s novel, penned by Mr. Trumbo, also confers its star Ginger Rogers a golden opportunity to strut her stuff, not her usual terpsichorean nimbleness, but her acting bent, and its reward is a hard-earned Oscar statuette, pipping strong contenders like Bette Davis in THE LETTER (1940, 8.0/10), Joan Fontaine in REBECCA (1940, 8.3/10) and Katharine Hepburn in THE PHILADELPHIA STORY (1940, 8.1/10).
After a prologue demonstrating the victory of gender equity in the beginning of twentieth century, here comes our heroine Kitty Foyle (Rogers), a New York saleswoman from Philadelphia, facing a difficult choice, there are two suitors awaiting her at midnight, one is doctor Mark Eisen (Craig) who loves her affectionately and another is her sweetheart Wyn Strafford (Morgan), whom she is enamored with, but a married man now who proposes that they can start anew in South America. When dithering about her decision, the film segues through a series of flashbacks (à la PENNY SERENADE 1941)with a snow globe as its mnemonic cue, detailing Kitty’s past entanglement with those two men, especially with Wyn, from their first meeting in Philly, their romance is congenially tainted by their social echelons, Wyn is from a prosperous banker’s family and she is merely his secretary, a rubberneck of the Assembly which Wyn attends annually. Acting in accordance with its woman-empowering tenet, the film vouchsafes Kitty a carte blanche by suggesting that Wyn is too meek and callow to make up his own mind. So Kitty leaves Philly when she knows a wedding proposal is too quixotic at that point, and in NYC, she is courted by Mark, who is the opposite of Wyn’s opulence, with a slightly prosaic air of practicality.
Life’s vagaries again bring Wyn to her, this time with a sincere marriage proposal and lavish pageantry to swoon her, they tie the knot, but reality check creeps in when Kitty has to face Wyn’s family and their unrelieved gentility, once more she braves herself to cut the Gordian knot. There are more hammer blows await her but as a paragon of modern woman with an absolutely righteous mind, Kitty proves herself a real hoop-jumper, and this time, she will make a right choice once and for all.
Ms. Rogers is most sympathetic when she brings forth Kitty's fortitude in the face of adversities, but the story’s emotional potency is detrimentally hampered by the white-washing of the hardship of being an independent woman surviving in a big city by all herself, Kitty is presented with an ineradicable veneer of silver screen allure which inexorablyrenders the tonality a shade condescending and contrived to any audience who chances upon it in the 21st century. Two supporting stars,Dennis Morgan and James Craig both make a great impression as an open-faced, suave gentleman without wiles, what differentiates them is where do they come from, not a bad marriage advice for today’s singletons although the film itself is as workmanlike as it is anodyne, a typical end product of Hollywood in thrall of production code,but not exactly a "natural" history of a woman.
referential points: Sam Wood’s THE DEVIL AND MISS JONES (1941, 7.2/10),George Steven’sPENNY SERENADE (1941, 7.0/10)
纠结但不矫情的三角恋,鲜明而自然的角色设定,俊美的脸蛋儿更让人入戏。Dennis Morgan, James Craig
Ginger依然是心中性感女神,越老越有味道,本片一举获得年度最佳室友,年度最尴尬约会,年度最成熟21岁,年度最佳陆毅模仿秀四项提名,其中年度最佳陆毅模仿秀这个奖项拿奖几乎没有悬念
3.5/5 可惜了啊 这本子给塞克拍 能高个档次啊
说句不着调的:上世纪三四十年代美国王漫妮的爱情生活故事。
Ginger就算专门拍剧情片也会是个很好的演员,跟Fred在一起拍歌舞片是有点压制了她的表演天赋的。
1940年的电影已经告诉我们灰姑娘这种童话故事往往终结于生活真正开始的地方。Beautiful Ginger Rogers
虽然喜欢Ginger但是她这次拿奥斯卡应该是沾了角色的光,不是说她表现不好,但是同一年提名的女演员都非常好,不过Kitty这个角色痴情热情专情,结尾选择婚姻家庭,符合被辜负的好女人形象。电影整体挺中规中矩的那种好看,几次雪球闪回到后来有点疲劳
FINALLY OSCARS
有没有人觉得Dennis Morgan的角色很令人反感?
父亲的水晶球,逗趣的女室友,刻字的酒瓶子,败选的共和党,古老的费城家族,五岁的前夫之子……以及不知道谁说过的老话:一个人终归会选择去见医生。
很迷琴逑的发亮大眼&高挑气质,通片看下来编排还蛮棒的,情节上有点像琼瑶的《秋歌》。承认吧,爱在阶级面前大部分时候还是要低头的,你怎么能指望生活事业完全仰仗豪门的男主阔少跟女主过穷日子呢?琴逑最后的离开很是潇洒明智,只是40s初就加入怀孕堕胎元素未免太偶像剧了。2020.08.01-08.03
7.5,有些地方绕有趣味嘛,金格也是赞,风趣可爱又独立自主,难得痕迹又淡。爱情也要建立在独立的人格之上,做不了自己怎么可能得到属于自己的爱情?
Dennis Morgan的小嘴歪的真性感。
不是每一个没有太多才华却顽固偏激的女人都像Kitty Foyle 那么幸运,在最后时刻仍有选择的余地。
不明白为什么女主一次次离开,又一次次等待男主来找。什么毛病啊~~
对镜自语同框剪辑,怎么也转不过去的水晶球。工厂造星年代,29岁的金姐一脸沧桑。
过去的就让他滚 来来回回不像样
7.6 女权题材,剧本叙事工整,没什么高明之处,着重塑造一位令人喜爱的独立自强的女性形象,放到如今有点像是那种冲着表演奖去的影片,好在金吉罗杰斯表演足够优秀,所有这些对于这种表演挑大梁的影片已经最够好了。
还不错,打破美国梦,试图用一种女权的视角去审视爱情,但正如开片展示的那样对女权的理解有些偏颇。人家那时就在宣扬不要拜金,现在咱们却尽是嫁入豪门就能过上好生活的韩剧节奏,明显意识上就不正确嘛。片子讲得有点慢了,但颇具说服力,金吉跟角色很搭。讲童话的人很聪明总是不到结局就把故事结束了
女性的独立自主让她们在恋爱和婚姻的思想中更加自由,但现实依然是残酷的,拨开爱情的烟雾弹才是女主人公最终选择的路。金格尔的眼睛很美,表演的很细腻。感谢鲸鱼奶奶的辛苦翻译和可乐大神的辛苦校对。DL:http://t.cn/8spMLCW or http://t.cn/8spMLCl