1 ) 18年,给你看爱情的未来
引文:作为前两部浪漫小品的延续,堕入婚姻的第三部显然再浪漫不起来,但一地鸡毛之下,也有相濡以沫的绵密悠长。
18年,给你看爱情的未来
文/米粒
暑假结束,儿子汉克从度假地希腊返回美国,杰西送机。14岁少年和老爸无话,所有的发问,回答都只是几个字。但从谈话中依然可知,杰西已和前妻离婚,儿子跟妈妈生活在芝加哥,他则长居欧洲。
杰西走出机场大厅。妻子席琳在车上等他,后排,双胞胎女儿已睡熟。原来,2004年《爱在日落黄昏时》杰西和席琳巴黎偶遇,之后已发生这么多变动。
《爱在午夜降临前》是一个爱情文艺三部曲的第三部,前两部分别为《爱在黎明破晓前》、《爱在黄昏日落时》,每两部之间相隔9年。导演都是理查德·林克莱特;主演都是朱莉·戴比和伊桑·霍克,第一部上映时,两人分别为26和25岁,第二部35、34岁,今年44、43岁。
18年前,美国青年杰西乘火车游历欧洲,在返美前一天,偶遇法国美女席琳,两人相谈甚欢,于是一起在维也纳下车,随意在城里游走,天文地理、哲学宗教、爱情家庭,无所不聊。席琳得知,杰西此次欧洲之行是因被前女友抛弃,而席琳也刚刚结束一段感情。浪漫的一夜过后,两人决定不去理那个“不再见”的约定,约好6个月后在火车站见面。
时间一晃,到了2004年,杰西已成知名作家,并把自己和席琳的故事写成小说,来欧洲签售。在最后一站巴黎,席琳出现在书店的人群中。原来9年前她因祖母去世没能赴约。此时杰西已结婚生子,席琳也有稳定的男友。变得成熟的两人在很多话题上更加放得开,都表示9年前那一夜之后对对方无法释怀。席琳答应在杰西去机场前给他唱一首歌,一曲《华尔兹》之后,杰西似乎明白了什么。
又一个9年。杰西送走儿子,和席琳驱车前往友人处继续假期。十多分钟的长镜头里,两人随意聊着:席琳得到一个工作机会,正纠结是否接受,因为之前两人讨论要不要搬回美国和汉克住得更近,而这份工作在巴黎。
晚饭后,两人准备亲热,却接到汉克报平安的电话,于是不可避免地继续谈起影片开始的话题:要不要搬回美国。气氛开始变得严肃而紧张:席琳抱怨杰西心里想搬回芝加哥嘴上却不承认,从女儿出生到现在做家务的都是自己;杰西反驳说自己多年来一直在迁就老婆反而被责备。两人一句接着一句吵,席琳说自己“当年还有弹吉他的爱好,都是因为你才没能继续”,杰西则说“要不是你那首歌,我的生活也不会变成现在这样子”。席琳摔门而去,抛下一句“我想我已经不爱你了”。
结尾处,午夜,席琳独坐发呆。杰西走过去,用“来自未来的陌生人”的口吻给她念了一封“信”,告诉她八十多岁时他们仍在一起,而这个希腊的夜晚是浪漫而难忘的。镜头慢慢拉远,席琳终于开口,“那么今晚真的是信里说的这样吗?”两人的对话变得模糊难以辨认,只有晴朗的夜色和平静的海。
作为前两部浪漫小品的延续,堕入婚姻的第三部显然再浪漫不起来,但一地鸡毛之下,也有相濡以沫的绵密悠长。
和前两部相同的是,《爱在午夜降临前》同样保持了结局上的开放性。5月初翠贝卡电影节的纽约首映礼上,观众对于两人是否和好便是见仁见智。
历时18年的这三部电影,被封为“话唠”文艺片,内容就是一天一夜之间两位主角的不断移动和喋喋不休。话题虽十分发散,但最终都会回到两性关系这一主题。两个小时看下来,不觉得闷,全靠两位主角的表演和台词的字字珠玑。表演太过真实,让人忍不住产生“这是不是即兴演出”的疑问,以为搞不好就是把摄影机打开然后两个人随意发挥,但导演回答说每一句台词都是剧本里事先写好,每一场戏都要一次又一次地排练直至精确为止。上一部《日落》曾给3人带来奥斯卡最佳原创剧本的提名,这一次应该有同样的竞争力。
这种对同一组人在不同年龄进行呈现的拍摄方式,除三部曲外大概只有英国的成长系列纪录片和弗朗索瓦·特吕弗的安托万系列,而它以对话为主的模式则让人想到同样也是啰啰嗦嗦探讨两性关系的埃里克·侯麦,但三部曲的独到之处也是显而易见的:从二十出头对未来无限向往,到再度邂逅的美好,再到探讨中年危机,就如旁观一对爱人的私人生活史,让人忍不住反观自己的生活并进行某种思考。
作为这一代美国独立电影导演的代表,林克莱特有很多作品聚焦于叛逆少年(《年少轻狂》、《摇滚校园》、《都市浪人》),角度独特,台词多,并挖掘了很多德州当地的故事(《伯尼》)。伊桑·霍克说他是这一代人中“真正的成熟的艺术家”。和他同时期的独立片导演中,索德伯格已宣布息影,昆汀沉迷血浆,大卫·林奇什么都干就是不拍片。
伊桑·霍克一直投身于舞台剧,也创作电影剧本。朱莉·戴比近年来自导自演的几部电影《纽约两日情》、《巴黎两日情》等,也是让人刮目相看。《爱在午夜降临前》的剧本,便是3位挚友精诚合作的结果。
虽然每部都是独立的故事,但把3部电影连在一起看,会发现其中有很多细节相映成趣。第一部中,杰西和席琳互扮对方好友,“接电话”听对方吐露心声,包括对对方的感觉这样无法直接出口的话题;《午夜》结尾处,杰西借“从未来回来的他”之口告诉席琳八十多岁时他们仍然在一起。第一部中,席琳告诉杰西,她会因为了解到更多的细节而更爱对方,看《午夜》时会忍不住想,看到彼此这么多细节的两人,真的更爱对方了吗?
(刊于《人物》2013年6月)
2 ) 卿卿我我不如放声大吵
1.其实这个系列的全球受落并不只是表面的情情爱爱(当然情情爱爱是必杀技也难怪我那个80末的小女同事也爱看),而是准确呈现人不同阶段的状态,20岁的无限憧憬到30岁的全盘幻灭,
40岁,肯定是一地鸡毛了。
2.作为单身怪胎肯定比其他人难代入,同龄是同龄,中年也是中年,唯独这次目标观众是婚龄长兼有娃的爹妈。我只能打个酱油。
3.看开头就皱眉,哪有老夫老妻还这么热衷交谈的?还是在车里?后来男女主角贴心台词注脚,哎呀上次这么热聊都不记得啥时候了。
4.ethan和作家朋友谈新作,立刻waking life乱入。
5.饭桌戏几代同堂,特意设年轻couple作对应,忆当年;又借老年智者之口解释relationship内涵,煞费苦心,但还不算片眼。
6.一路卿卿我我戏看得不来劲,终于到了最后吵起来,
这就对了嘛,这才像两口子撒。
看过的电影里可类比的,张元拍王朔的我爱你,神经质上身;库布里克的大开眼戒,猜疑嫉妒不信任的金童玉女档,
林克莱特三人帮的这版,算是最真实最接地气的吧。
7.10年前茱莉大发作是,点解老娘谈了n次恋爱男人都不靠谱捏!
如今再次大发作是,死男人你知否老娘又要上班又要带孩子还要跟着你大作家去签售做成功男人背后的女人老娘很不爽老娘不想只做家庭主妇你知不知道!
全球知识女性观众此刻怕是要齐刷刷转过头对着老公说,看见没有!她说的就是我要说的!
8.也但愿每个这样的女人,身边坐着个和戏里同样耐心的老公陪她看到最后,看两口子终于消停下来,等字幕起,再拖着她缓缓走出影院。
大概这是三人帮最想看到的观众反馈。
9.最可爱的还是细节,老两口的戏码特真实。吵到最后吵出屋了,老好人老公低三下气求和了,特浪漫特煽情的话来一番。
20来岁的时候,最后来一拥吻特写;30岁的时候谈谈吉他唱唱歌;40岁,这招不太管用了,少来这套啊,甜言蜜语的听10年了耳朵听出茧了,女人还是不依不饶。
好脾气老公也恼了,我说你这女人有完没完!吼了一番。
女人总算是乖了,行行行,也闹得差不多了,午夜之前,大概这片名的意思就是,
夫妻仇不过夜嘛。
10.甜蜜逛街的长镜头里,我一直盯着两只手看,那一男一女两只手,蹭来蹭去你撞我啊我撞你,但就是没有变成,手牵手。
所以说啊,有时候有时候,我会相信一切有尽头,当年的眉目传情蜜里调油双手紧握,不再有啊不再有。
不过,从巴黎到希腊,等到风景都看透,还是你陪着我在看细水长流。
3 ) 别说什么这就是真实,我跟你在一起不是为了真实
第一部真实吗?第二部真实吗?
该分就分,不爱就不爱了承认又如何。
出轨也出了,吵架也吵疲了,jesse和所有男人一样觉得自己做的很好了,Celine的一腔愤怒被人当神经病。
美好已经消磨殆尽,两人在一起只是互相忍耐罢了,没错儿这就是结局,但你们也可以选择转身离开,留一个美好的回忆,而不是邋遢的吵个不停。
谢谢晚会儿联系,拍出了这个结局,就是稍微作了点儿,片尾那个貌似美好的段落透着假惺惺。真希望jesse不要跟出来,celine一人坐了整晚。这才是好结局。
> 修改 > 删除
4 ) To passing through.
很喜歡那位老太太的獨白,錄于此:
Well, when I think of Corpileas, what I missed most about him is, the way he used to lie down next to me at night.
Sometimes his arms would stretch along my chest and I could’t move, I even held my breath.
But I felt safe, complete.
And I miss the way he was whistling walking down the street.
And every time I do something I think of what he would say: well it’s cold today, wear a scarf.
But lately, I’ve been forgetting little things, it’s sort of fading... And... I’m starting to forget him. And it’s like...like losing him again.
So sometimes I made myself remember him every detail of his face, the exact color of his eyes, his lips, his teeth; the texture of his skin, his hair. But it was all gone by the time he went.
And sometimes...not always but sometimes, I can actually see him.
It’s as if a cloud moves away and there he is, I could almost touch him. But then, Doria, well, rushes in and he vanishes again.
Well I did this every morning, when the sun was not too bright outside. The sun, somehow makes him vanish.
Yes he appears, he disappears, like...sunrise, or sunset, or anything so ephemeral.
Just like our life, hmm? We appear, and we disappear, and we are so important to some, but we are just... passing through.
...To passing through.
5 ) There's no fairy tale.
I'm just trying to make things better here.
I tell you I love you unconditionally, I tell you that you're beautiful, I tell you that your ass looks great when you are 80.
I'm trying to make you laugh.
I've put up with plenty of your shit.
If you think I'm just some dog that's gonna keep coming back, then you're wrong.
But if you want true love, then this is it.
This is real life, it's not perfect but it's real, and if you can't see it then you're blind.
6 ) the Pretentious, the Presumptuous and the Preposterous
"The difference between a caprice and a lifelong passion is that a caprice lasts longer." When the great Oscar Wilde wrote this sentence, he probably didn't expect that three people (Richard Linklater, Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy) would make a movie to vividly and thoroughly interpret this famous sentence of his. 'Before Sunrise' was all about caprice. An American guy spent a night with a French girl in Vienna. They flirted, drank, laughed, had sex and parted before the Sun rose again. The night passed by pleasantly with all the pretentious conversations between two typical twenty-some pseudo-intellectuals. He felt like a different person with her; she wanted to be lost in this beautiful dream. Although it's a corny one-night stand with an even cheesier poem inserted weirdly into the middle of the film, 'Before Sunrise' demonstrates how every love story starts. As two people connect and fall in love, they present to each other the best versions of themselves, the no-liability view on life and the impractical ideals about relationship.
Nine years later, when 'Before Sunset' caught up, the honeymoon stage was long gone and the bitterness just kicked in. Instead of talking about '911' or any major events that had happened (since both of them were in New York for some time), the two people assumed that the other was better off in his or her life. He wondered why she never showed up; she found it unfair that he became successful while she was aging and trapped in failed relationships. The presumptuous thing about knowing a person by just a little bit is that one forgets that a story, by default, has to be interesting. Both the storytellers and listeners tend to omit the intermittent uneventfulness, hence the illusion and insecurity of other people's lives being more exciting than their own.
Eventually through all the things that didn't work, the man and the woman realized what was most important for them and got together. Another nine years later, they took the offer to spend a romantic night away from the kids and the mid-life crisis but the fighting couldn't stop, not even by sex. 'Before Midnight' darkened and deepened the two characters' relationship, it was brutally honest about life's toll on couple, its impatience on love and its immunity to communication. When passion becomes commitment and sacrifice; man becomes a rationalist without emotion, woman a philosopher without reasoning.
Recently I had a conversation with a friend about how long it would take to know your partner in a relationship. While I argued that it takes as long as it gets, my friend confidently claimed that one month, at most, should be more than enough to know all the things needed to know about the other person. His Charlotte Lucas "Don't ask, don't tell" style made me wonder: how can a person be sure of the love of his life just by meeting her twice over 9 years? At the end of 'Before Midnight', Jesse himself answered my question: he threw away everything because of Celine's little waltz; he put up with all the craziness because he decided to "miss that plane". The ultimate answer to the Before trilogy is that love is about the good, the bad and the ugly. There is no such ending as happily ever-after. After going through the pretentious, the presumptuous and the preposterous, the finale of love is a conscious choice, a decision to take a chance with someone, to give to him or her without asking why. So I guess there is no fairy tale here, just great sex in the Southern Peloponnese of Greece.
他们的爱情一直让我想到哈利对莎莉最后的表白,“如果你知道自己想和谁一起度过余生,你会希望余生开始得越早越好。”十八年,从相遇相爱到这一部中被生活历练过的爱,柴米油盐和时间没有磨平爱情,反而让爱变成了一种习惯,太了解彼此,于是越来越难戒掉。期待九年后的续集了!★★★★★
虽然之前的争吵真实得让人糟心,但结尾逐渐拉远的镜头仍让人感动。前两部的浪漫与激情都变成了书里的故事,这一部则完全生活下来。各种鸡毛蒜皮的琐事只是一个假设,关于如何让爱延续一生。生活中总会有这样那样的矛盾,人也会变老(比如半裸的朱莉·德尔佩却很难让你觉得性感)问题是我们如何挨过去。
黎明和黄昏后最自然最真实的承接。年轻时对爱情,社会以及人生的观点和展望被中年后那些围绕着家庭,婚姻以及职业展开的争吵和不满所替代。即便如此,依旧是妙语连珠,吐不完的激情和浪漫。若不是当初的深情,怎会有今夜的碰撞?片尾那封来自未来的信设计得太美妙了。让我们9年后再相见吧。
十八年后他们变成了相遇那天火车上喋喋不休争吵摔门的德国夫妇
“我虽努力,却难于去亲近自己心爱的人”经历了平淡、争吵、否定、相濡以沫所有最真实的感情状态,18年过后,最难的是仍对彼此保有激情。上一次看到这么纯粹的爱情电影,还是九年前。伊桑朱莉理查请你们9年后准时回来,哪怕拍不动了、聊不起了、原地静坐90分钟,也好啊。期待2022年的第四部。
"We appear and we disappear, and we're important to some, but we're just passing through. "
为什么要结婚为什么要生小孩为什么要毁掉自己的生活
浪漫是浪漫,生活是生活。爱 是爱。这是三件事。它们相互不矛盾,不对立,它们只是,很难统筹兼得。(看到有恋人在我这条微薄里留言给另一半:“想在你拥有我的日子里,给你一个三者并包的人生。”默默地说,祝福你们!)
飞一般的超越,硬生生的被朱莉的嘴炮给弄哭了。。那些随口就能背诵莎士比亚台词的人们是多么的可恶啊!那些吃个下午茶都在谈哲学谈人生的人们是多么可憎啊!那些连夫妻吵架都引经据典的男女是多么可怕啊!对彼此来说我们多么重要,可最终还是过客,我失去你,不是以死亡为界,而是再一次。。再一次。。
为了看第三部,特意重温了前两部。还把《恋人絮语》找出来读了下。期待第四部Before Death(爱在棺材盒盖时)……
第一部时还愿意有更多的转换场景,更多的配乐,更多的更像电影的呈现方式。到此时,电影本身就是生活本身。这是导演的野心,也是自信。交谈、争吵与和好,争论与妥协。其实,他们还是18年前那一对年轻的男女。抓住人心的不是电影,永远都是生活本身。
“他们竟然____了”模式开启。从爱情的偶然到爱情的实然,浪漫也终于被相处的实用性取代。“就像日出日落,我们出现,我们消失,可最终只是经过。”那些琐碎的争吵怨念放在时间的河里似乎也就不算什么了。他最后向她朗读了一封40年后的来信——原来前18年还只是序曲,我流泪了...
所以说想要长久地在一起,必须是有一方一直不厌烦地陪着做戏。
能让所有投入的心血精力时间感情不白费功夫,除了宽容忍让,就是彼此的幽默和释怀,纯粹的完全真实的百分之百的爱情无法存活,请接受对方的缺点和过错,忽略皱纹和唠叨;幻想和另一个谁会有更好结局,至多让你有勇气谈论“爱”,这是奢侈的虚伪的笨拙的;请接受眼前现状吧。
真好,你还能让我一次又一次的爱上。
只有我关注引发吵架的生活问题其实一个都没解决吗?
作为Before的系列路,我终于在中年危机这里转了粉。Sunrise太甜,Sunset偏酸,只有Midnight酸甜苦辣都入了味。数度被台词戳中,我不得不一再提醒自己:那些只是台词,它们不是真的。
第三部反而代入感特别强了,感觉在女主身上看到几十年后那个依然很作的自己,人愿意来哄你就已经很好了,女文青这脾气啊,真是不适合生活的典型,做不到三从四德逆来顺受,给一点爱就受宠若惊,完全以男方为中心就不是贤良淑德了么,反正我也做不到。再过56年我也还是现在这个挑剔,别扭的脾气。
结婚快10年互相之间还有这么多话可讲,还有性生活,这他妈不是真爱是什么?
真实的不像话。换在9年前,我会看不下去两人婚后的絮絮叨叨、不断地吵架及和好,放到现在,却“心有戚戚焉”。互相折磨、互相伤害、互相妥协、并肩前行。爱人只不过是“经过”了你生命的那个人,而这份“经过”也请好好珍惜。