JOJO的奇妙冒险 星尘斗士

第三部引入了替身这个概念让战斗更烧脑，但是还是更喜欢看第一二部那种纯粹的勇气的颂歌。从一二部过来有一个很大的不适应之处在于，这一部的节奏太慢了，一共有48集。虽然每个替身的能力和设定都很有意思，但是这种一看标题就大概知道剧情的模式战线拉太长了，降低了期待感，一看标题就知道这个替身需要打多少集，还需要多久才能到开罗。

并且因为主角团人太多了，难免有人设重叠的部分，有时候就强行降智或者工具人。人设不一致看着非常难受，特别是各种对队友的不信任，强行莽，感觉他们就是非常放松的旅行团，每个人对自己的实力都有绝对的自信，根本没考虑过分工合作啥的，还好敌人也一个一个送，要是多个敌人围攻，我觉得早就凉了。也不是认为要强行突出友情团魂之类，相反我非常欣赏在紧要关头不会出现队友救人的场景。但是我觉得大家都算聪明人，在一起反而没有1+1＞2的效果，单线作战反而更出彩，团队战几乎都会出现有人降智的情况，让人摸不着头脑。

还有为了贴近校园生活开头弄的一群花痴女和为了丰富沉默寡言阿强的温柔人设强行加入的小女孩，让我差点弃剧，小女孩走了以后我才松了一口气。因为主角是高中生，也更加优柔寡断，更多的是再起不能之类，总的来说不如前一季看起来爽，画风也没有前一部好看，荒木线太明显了，弹幕质量也超级差，玩梗和饭圈那套太多了。

以下均为个人主观感受，含剧透。

很好看。跟第一部和第二部比起来要好看得多——前两部我打了四星。两个月前我开始看第一部的时候，是看《银魂》被伤到、看不下去的空窗期，正在慢悠悠地看《虫师》抚慰心灵。朋友给我推荐其他我要求的“不动脑子”“搞笑”的番已经排成长列，但我突然就很想看没人推的JoJo。于是就看了。当时每天午睡前会看番，如果是想慢慢进入睡眠状态，就会看《虫师》；如果是想多看一会儿，就看JoJo。以这样的进度，第一部和第二部我看了两个多月——没有非看不可的感觉，随时都能停下来，哪怕是知道接下来有关键情节，也能立刻退出去不看。但是第三部我花了两天半就看完了——就在一口气看完第二部最后四集的当天，马上开始第三部。很少能有让我什么都不想做只想看下去的番，在这之前只有《排球少年》——连着两天看到凌晨四点。

好看在哪。角色塑造得很好。每个人物都很鲜明，很有特色。我非常非常喜欢二乔，喜欢他的“皮”，喜欢他的勇敢、聪明。角色的声优杉田智和，配了《银魂》里的主角坂田银时，坂田银时和二乔的性格有一些相似之处，声优的声线也恰到好处。我非常喜欢。反派也都很有意思。有猥琐懦弱的，也有正直纯洁的。二乔和瓦姆乌的决斗让我印象很深刻，两个坚定信念、尊重战斗的人把这场决斗升华了。后来第三部里出现了很多替身使者，各具特色，都很有趣，让人可以一一道来那种。对主角团的刻画很细致：每个人的表情动作，喜好和习惯，对同一件事作出的不同的反应，使用技能的方式，无不体现性格和能力，非常立体。

还有让我很佩服的情节描写。每一个替身使者都让我充满期待——会有什么奇怪的技能，又是怎么被破解的。我觉得作者想到这么多巧妙又强大的能力很了不起，还要考虑主角用什么方法利用现有的条件获得胜利。一招一式，有来有往，斗智斗勇，让我很是惊叹。而且在这些内容里，逻辑一直是自洽的，没有出现明显错误，观感很不错。我不时会冒出“原来是这样的啊”“这都能想到”“设计得真好啊”“好牛啊”这类想法。相对于前两部，我认为这一部更加有章可循，让我能理解他们的战斗体系，而不是像前面的一些设定让我感觉随意突然而且自说自话。我对于前两部的评价是“抓马”，尤其是第一部，节奏很快，匆匆交代了很多背景和设定，让我感觉事情走向过于草率，又非常有戏剧性。但是第三部我不会用这个词评价了——一切都合理了起来。粗略看了其他评论，看到有朋友说战斗不如某某番，我感觉还挺惊讶的——比这个还好看？！我真是太没见识了。在我心里JoJo已经很厉害了。

但是我不喜欢有解说的番——这部里解说就没停过。我不喜欢是因为我感觉把所有事都说出来太做作太刻意了，不能自然地表达设定和细节是作品本身的问题——但是JoJo实在太例外了……不解说根本不行，我等凡人没解说看不懂，但我还是觉得好尴尬啊……我还不太能接受的是第三部里二乔怎么这么倒霉又迟钝啊……二乔变老我比死了还难受……

我还比较喜欢的是作者对于人物的死亡和受伤的处理——指很干脆地让重要人物残疾或死亡。这是一种魄力。JoJo本身是宏大叙事，跨越的时间和空间都很大，人事有代谢，人物受伤死亡是很正常的。作者会毫无铺垫地让重要人物甚至主角受重伤或死亡，让我反省是不是很久没看过类似的处理了。我印象中，很多剧情都是铺垫很多很多、观众都哭过好几轮了，才依依不舍地让角色死掉，而且后面还会反复鞭尸，只要一提到观众又会嚎叫。这样看来，我已经被“温柔”对待太久了——还有很多是被剧透了。但是JoJo这样我反而感觉挺舒服的。对于角色来说，愿意为了信念果断地牺牲自己、为逝去的朋友缅怀但不沉溺其中仍然大步向前走，是很符合主旨的，也让我感觉很棒。第三部里阿布德尔的死就让我很意外，感觉毫无预兆，但慢慢接受了这个事实——回来得也很毫无预兆。据说回来是因为作者受到了部分读者的影响，但是不妨碍假死的时候的干脆。

最后说一下画风吧。我之前没看过这么“狂野”的番，所以很不适应它的画风。后来慢慢变顺眼了，但是也不是完全接受。不过，不影响我觉得主角很帅。

感觉下一部不能看这么快了。但是还是馋。

终于，在第三遍观看后，方才体会到了一个个硬汉面孔后鲜活的灵魂：看了三遍为之落泪了三次的Iggy。最后舍身救友不是所谓的狗的忠诚，而是在自由意志驱使下的无怨无悔的牺牲。“野狗也有高贵的灵魂”，荒木再一次将“黄金精神”的定义扩展至一切可能的存在，将这一理念一步步移下神坛，展现其在世界万物之上的普适性。能思考到这一层也是我对荒木极其佩服的一点。//花京院典明则是新·心动对象（前提是重温前看了很多同人图get了其美貌ww)。刚柔并济，观察敏锐，又极有行动力，处刑曲「高潔なる教皇」也好听到不行。//人狠话不多的承太郎，老当益壮的二乔，重情重义的波波，老成持重的阿布，也都为这部壮烈史诗留下了浓墨重彩的一笔。

然后总结为什么看了三遍才被征服。。。

1⃣️替身系统还处于开发阶段，荒木终究没有能够如后几部那般，凝练地展现每个替身的能力和魅力。众多互相矛盾、或是有用完即丢的设定、缺少首尾相连的合理性，着实遗憾。

2⃣️“百年恶人”Dio前期各种烘托强大魅惑冷静高傲，但最终一战属实失态。过度的嚣张不仅造成ooc，还让最终一战缺少了“宿命之终结”的悲壮感。

3⃣️人物统一硬汉画风，五人一狗中唯一的“美人”花京院看着非常鬼畜，人物特点没能通过画面很好地传达（幸亏平川大辅声音拯救），观感大打折扣。

4⃣️后期节奏有问题，三番两次在感人情节后无缝衔接搞笑片段，令人恼火。

Stardust Crusaders (2014) is Jojo's Bizarre Adventure : the Animation (2012)'s sequel. But if you think about it seriously, there are a thousand things that are different between the two seasons, and which make undoubtedly SEASON 1 > SEASON 2. To some extent, you could speak of a DIFFERENT anime.
I took a quick look on the reviews of other websites a moment ago : senscritique (barely), anidb (clearly) & anime news network (surely) all agree with me on which season is better, only douban doesn't and that can be explained easily : the community of douban does not understand SHIT to anime. All hail anidb !

Since I consider Jojo's Bizarre Adventure the Animation (2012 = season 1) as the best shounen anime of all time, this review is mostly going to be a comparison between the two, a comparison between the Master and the student.

Characters : Stardust Crusaders' has the worst Jojo so far. His look is definitely GAR, but the "R" in here is getting too much closer to an "Y". The chain on his neck, the hat on his head and that stupid cape make his design far less enjoyable than the two first ones.
Personality wise, he is an empty shell, and this hurts even more since they had 24 episodes to develop him, whereas they had far less for the two previous Jojo's who had to share out the 24 episodes.
When the two first Jojo's had a few first episodes to lay down some background (usually without much fights or as an appetizer) and stories in order to introduce the protagonists, their values & skills (honesty & raw force for the first, naughtiness & smartness for the second), this one only gets the bare minumum. The end result is that there will be no empathy for the character during the whole show. This 3rd Jojo's has almost no dialogue lines : he looks cold, avoids to talk, does the job (i.e. the killing) when necessary and contains all his emotions. The "Yare yare" (Good grief) that he keeps on repeating in every circumstance is DEFINITELY not cool...
This goes to the extent that we might at some point doubt who is the main character... since this one does not get so much attention when the stories unfolds, & the creator focuses more on the other characters. This is also a big difference with the first season, in which one Jojo's is the boss & the others are only there in a support (Zeppeli the teacher) / secondary (Zeppeli the descendant) / commentary (Speedwagon) role and usually end up dying or beat up.
In Stardust Crusaders, there are actually TWO Jojo's simultaneously. One plays the role of the Dark Powerful Silent Protagonist and the second of the Experienced Funny Talkative "secondary" character. + 3 other characters that actually get a lot of attention and a bit of development (especially Polnareff) : Avdol (the Wise & Temperate guy) whose Stand skills are Power & Fire, Kakyoin (Common Sense & Stabilising member of the group) whose Stand skills are Flexibility & Variety, Polnareff (the Silly & Funny guy with whom the viewer will often adopt the subjective point of view : i.e. Avdol's death) and whose Stand skills are Precision & Velocity. Of course the characters are created so that there is an Equilibrium & Complementarity in the group, and so that no one is powerful enough for overtaking the Protagonist's role. Classicaly, who will face the new bad guy depends on the powers that they each have, and on how powerful is the enemy. Sometimes they will face altogether some enemies which is pretty cool in terms of interaction and symbiosis.

Development (structure & fights) : Far less epic than Stardust Crusaders for many reasons. One of them is that there are too many enemies (representing for some weird reasons a card in the Tarot game, which is not adding anything to the show - except perhaps selling the fucking cards later ?). On average, each new enemy has a two-episodes span life, including half an episode of silly jokes and progress in the map, a cool or stealth entrance, the fight lasting 1 episode with a couple of predictable twists and then a conclusion with everyone being happy and teaching the bad guy a good lesson. It's almost a pokemon-like structure... The worst is that Dio never appears in any fight... He is far away "waiting" for the characters in the darkness, raping bitches and looking strong & cool with the Jojo's family star on his back. This again reminds a lot of the old european cartoons of the 90's, in which the main antagonist keeps sending small fries without moving his ass, while he's posing and showing his best evil laughter. The show is structured in a way that we know at each episode that the bad guy is going to get his ass kicked and that a new one is coming next and so on... If the characters were not road tripping from Japan to Egypt and if we didn't know that opponents are limited in number (Dio will necessarily run out of those FUCKING Tarot cards), the anime would have been simply BORING. Hopefully the road trip enables to see different settings and is helping for building the jokes (toilets in India, 讨价还价 in Arab countries, rigorous rules in Singapore etc...). It goes without saying that the MYSTERY of season 1 (related to the Mask, to the ancient cultures evil forces etc.) is completely absent. In the first season, the stakes were generally much higher : badass & super dangerous enemies (including Dio and the mask's embodiments) with some depth & backstory would show up and give a real hard time for the protagonists (causing heavy injuries, deaths and big emotional fuss). In Stardust Crusaders, everything is too easy and taken lightly. Except once, all superficial injuries disappear at the end of the fight and, opponents come one by one and end up begging for their lives without any dignity.
And that leads us to one of the main points of this review : if you think about it in another way, one could argue that Jojo's is less of a shounen with serious fights than a funny comedy with loads of gag (adding the traveling adventure aspect, and it starts having a couple of common points with One Piece). This is not necessarily a critique, since the show is REALLY super funny, but mechanically less Epic and thrilling.

Other aspects : Aesthetically speaking, IMHO the first season's added effects were clearly better and engaging. They would for important moments, freeze the picture for a "cool phase" and add layers of colors and geometric forms all around in order to emphasize a situation and making it classy, usually during fights. This technique has sadly almost been abandoned in this anime... I thought it was brilliant in the first season. In the same spirit, moments when the colors of a given setting would start to beautifully distort and change are also less common in the sequel. The sceneries depicted were also more elaborate and beautiful in the latter.
Otherwise the animation of this sequel is really well-made, even though the artistic value is a bit inferior to the predecessor.
The music (including OP and especially the masterpiece song for the ending) is not as good as season 1 but still fits what's happening in the screen overall. The references to the rock n' roll & heavy metal world are also very rare compared to the first season, since the creators focused their references into general knowledge (geography, cultural aspects and bit of history) while describing the place where the characters stopped during their road trip.

Wish they do a sequel with more epicness, and with DIO !!!!!!! for God's sake.

处刑高潮时的音效感觉没有第二部热血澎湃，替身的能力特征也不像黄金之风那样明晰，毕竟当时荒木老师对替身能力的安排还处于摸索阶段呢。不过这一部每个故事慢慢展开时的悬疑节奏安排得不错，悬疑元素在这一部里的首次大量加入应该是相比于一二部的亮点，虽然悬疑音效略显单一，但与剧情配合得很好。 最喜欢巴基斯坦旅馆留宿、游乐场噩梦和许愿神灯那集，让我想起了高中时第一次看猛鬼街的感觉。哈哈，说实话荒木老师的想象力真是令人感到舒服，正好奇夜半荒岛的一千零一夜物语要如何展开，原来是个大礼包，意外。 不过，这样说来，黄金之风里每当敌人的替身能力在不知不觉中显露出来时也有好多悬疑气息，其中滚石篇个人甚觉是悬疑力量的大爆发。总之，不论是第三部还是黄金之风的确能感受到荒木老师中学时代阅读的那些悬疑小说的成果。感谢老师年少时的阅读习惯！！带给我们如此回味无穷的精神饕餮！！！

肉芽好像...黑头

海洋的那个藤壶长得密集死了，看了想立马④掉

这小女孩该不会就是...替身使者吧，好吧应该是这，不会以为自己是船长吧，老。

有点像鬼娃比利，

花京院该不会是老太婆儿子吧，也有可能是叫他要小心dio的手下。都说是假，那真哪里去了呢

本体还真挺帅的～

最开始以为那倒吊人遮住脸还挺帅，没想到丑得那叫一个抽象，还怪吓人的、、

那个人身体的大洞里该不会是，蛆吧，都已经被吸干了，妈妈呀，，

恩雅老太婆真是疯了，荷尔荷斯也真是蠢，自己赶去送人头，笑死。死得好吓人，打了个这么大的耳洞当成抽血机。

波波认贼作母，还挺可爱捏～

「恋人」是在玩SM，好美。还舔，妈呀原来自己是个M，笑晕

梦境这集真的好好看，

愿望肯定是让阿布德尔复活，妈呀？怎么，这是敌人？还以为真的是神呢...

波波该不会要死了吧，这替身是..阿布德尔的？

原来他们都知道没死，那他们之前埋得是什么？？就为了让波波一直内疚吗？

外公有我陪着

浩渺星空下，熊熊篝火旁，荒芜大漠中，深邃海洋里，50天，六个铁血男儿踏上这趟以爱和拯救为名的旅程，义无反顾。他们用自己的行动诠释了灵魂之崇高，而陪他们走了那么远之后我发现 根本无法不爱他们每一个。无敌的承太郎，睿智的花花，呆萌的波波，无私的阿布嘟嘟，狗比人勇的伊奇，还有我年老色衰，魅力却不减当年的二乔……荣耀属于星尘十字军！

其实看完第二部，陪有趣的二乔走过一程后，看到Jo太郎过于严肃的性格，开始真的接受不能，以为五十多集看下来大概会很闷，不想到最后居然被星辰十字军铁一般的决心和似火的斗志所打动，激动得跟着白金之星大喊欧拉欧拉欧拉，后来旅途过半又get到了卖鱼强的颜值，看到他沉着冷酷的样子就感觉很安心，那种笃定、内敛、沉稳正是他作为一个日本人所有的性格魅力。由此不得不感慨荒木真是太高明，英国的大乔绅士，美国的二乔活泼，日本的三乔严肃，意大利的五乔时尚（误）....人物的塑造极符合环境和背景的设定。

伊奇是最让我感动的，我本身喜爱狗子是一方面，另一方面，它虽然是一只狗，但它小小的身躯却有着狼一般的铮铮傲骨，有为朋友两肋插刀的热血，有为崇高事业舍生取义的觉悟。仍记得最后一战中，它明明已经被敌人踢得伤痕累累，可看到即将被吞噬的波波，奄奄一息的它还是做出了最终的抉择：它放弃内心向往着波澜不惊的狗生，为这个它平日正眼都不瞧的波波使出了最后的替身。破碎的愚者散落下来，覆盖了它小小的身体，断了的肋骨，充血的肺，这只狗耗尽自己的生命点燃了波波的生命，像完成任务一般，静静躺在那里了。本是渺小的，卑贱的，被轻蔑的，此刻却成了伟大的，高贵的，被尊崇的。它所拥有的，是不朽的灵魂。

花京院头脑冷静，细心睿智，说得上是Jo3里我最喜欢的人物。他最后的死实在是让人唏嘘不已，明知和Dio之间的实力差距悬殊，可他还是义无反顾，用最后的力量放出绿宝石水花，传递dio替身的秘密。一路走来，他都那么聪明谨慎，被戏称为团队的脑子；他也会像个孩子，吃樱桃的时候鬼畜得让人哑然失笑，他也会很腹黑，居心叵测地用典明粥去报复敌人，可最后我们才知道，真正的他其实孤单的。他是那么孤单，孤单了19年，不被理解，没有陪伴，直到这群人出现。是这群人让他明白，他不是怪物，这段旅程让他明白，相遇那一瞬的惊艳，值得用自身最宝贵的东西去交换......

也难怪在第四部中，承太郎知道仗助的替身后会说，真是温柔的能力啊.....

铭刻在记忆里的时光总是牵动人心吧，陪伴的分分秒秒总让人难以忘怀~也难怪我在第四部看到阿强，第五部看到波波时，竟会湿了眼眶……

这破动画居然有9.4分？脑残粉都滚开好吗，别在这儿误人子弟了好吗？真的受不了这种尬吹了。

如果说这部番的剧情在超神超鬼之间切换的话，那战斗起来真的就是大型的智商羞辱现场了。前两季的战地实况解说被增加到惹人厌烦的程度！

之前的解说镜头很明显交代了，虽然是正常语速但所有解说都只是发生在交锋的一瞬，这一部倒好，边打边说，要么说的时候看同伴挨揍，要么就是一边解说一边等着敌人揍自己。前半部完全成了秀替身能力的走过场，每个杀手(除了皇帝）都想着一打五，问题是他们只要几个人稍微配合一下，jojo他们新加坡都出不去。好，这就不说了，添油战术是很多动画的通病，但是口嗨强者跟自嗨智者呢？对的，说的就是波鲁那雷夫跟花京院。还有很多人尬吹的DIO，大兄弟们，DIO人设是第一部立起来的，放弃为人的高光时刻也不是三乔他们逼他实现的，这一部里对DIO除了尬吹就是尬吹，那DIO到底做了啥呢？躲在房间里种肉芽还是派手下挨个去送死？要知道DIO是个从不避讳群殴别人的真小人，不是个只知道看书睡女人的装逼犯啊。

另起一段说说二乔，jojo第二部，或者说第一部后半段，是我看过所有漫画中战斗描写最为出色的了，这里的战斗不看谁更能爆种，更重要的是智力的交锋，而在19岁的年纪凭借一己之力干掉月下三兄贵的二乔形象，不管放在哪部番，都是当之无愧的第一主角。无他，智与力的配合太过完美！

可是！可是！可是！到了这一步，二乔成了彻头彻尾的谐星，为了突出本作主角削弱上代主角的做法我可以接受，但是这边的二乔完全是套着乔瑟夫乔斯达马甲的…神棍老头。崩了呀荒木利之。

诚然，三乔这种巨装逼的形象看得大家挺过瘾的，到不能掩盖星尘斗士是一部优缺点都很明显的作品，9分番，抱歉，真的不配。