可然和阿俊

这个片子的主题：

因果循环，民众反抗暴政，爱情至上，亲情至上等等

这个片子的元素：

印度喜剧，南印歌舞，香港武打，美国西部，爱情，宗教（摩诃婆罗多＋迦梨），复仇，反抗，伦理（毕竟到底还是叔叔杀了侄子和他们爸，侄子们又杀了叔叔和他儿子的事情）等等

几乎每一个元素和主题，都处理得不错，至少75分吧，合起来当然值得更高分。

爱情的线相对处理得简单，套路一些，富家女爱上穷小子，男人婆爱上小冰山，不过处理得比较合理。

因为是个特别奔放自由的富家女，爱上会撩骚策马奔腾的穷小子。

会撩骚有抖M倾向的男人婆，爱上闷骚的小冰山。

亲情线是处理得最……浓烈的。

无论是长得一点也不像的母子关系还是长得一点也不像的双胞胎兄弟关系，如果放在西方电影，大概是恋母情结和恋兄恋弟情结，具体他们有多黏糊，感情又多深，就不说了，只说说他们的行为看起来合不合理。

我认为比较合理的地方是，母亲是个刚烈正直又仁慈的人，可能出身低微，吸引到一个善良朴实的地主儿子应该是可能的。为此地主儿子被老爸赶出家门，就在村里教书，生娃，一家四口比较快落。

后来坏蛋专业户叔叔，老地主的侄子杀了地主儿子，母亲看到这一幕就带着俩娃躲村里。

这个狗血的背景下，母亲在抚养两个儿子的时候一定难免倾注全部的爱恋，加上她自己的性格，所以孩子们也比较活泼正直并且恋母。

双胞胎设定放在这俩男主身上，其实很牵强，外形真的没有一处像的，他们就用最套路的方式：双胞胎默契，你说半句我说半句，你一个眼神，我一个眼神，你要干嘛我马上干嘛，这种行动默契弥补。

效果我觉得还行，至少兄弟我是信的，加上名字光环加持：

第一代，沙鲁克汗是阿周那，萨尔曼汗是奎师那（我觉得这俩梗不明显，奎师那还没有阿周那长得黑）

第二代，沙鲁克汗是Vijay，就是奎师那别名，萨尔曼汗是Aijay阿周那（这俩梗非常明显，奎师那弹弓车轮撩妹一应俱全，阿周那闷一点，听奎师那教导明白了卧槽原来我有妈）

第一代都没有点武力值，所以都被坏人叔叔虐杀。第二代阿周那的武力值是满的，全片最能打，看这个滚圆的胳膊，啊。

这也不得不提到复仇线，母亲是开端和终结。

最开始我看的时候觉得母亲看到杀夫仇人不复仇，是典型圣母白莲，后来……结合了一下印度那个阶层差距，大概懂了，一个首陀罗反抗高种姓结果，就是她两个儿子也会没。

但问题是，她不复仇，两个儿子也没了，于是她的生命就只剩下了，等儿子，复仇。

虽说有儿子工具人嫌疑哈，但她二十年坚守那句话“我的儿子会劈开大地来这里，他们会撕开天空来这里”，我觉得也不能完全用复仇解释。应该更多是一种信仰，这个信仰包含了创造与复仇女神迦梨的信仰，也包括血脉信仰，因果轮回信仰等等。

杜尔加（Rakhee）是一个寡妇，她一手抚养两个儿子卡兰（萨尔曼汗）和阿特瓦尔（沙鲁克汗）。他们被他们邪恶的叔叔Durjan辛格（Amrish普里）杀死，杜尔加向女神卡利祈祷，让她的儿子们回到她身边。卡伦和阿琼是重生的兄弟两人，但他们出生在不同的地方，不知道他们的过去。当他们回忆起自己以前的生活学习，他们联手报复Durjan辛格。

总之是重生与复仇的故事。。。

Durga (Rakhee) is a widow who has single-handedly raise her two sons Karan (Salman Khan) and Arjun (Shahrukh Khan). When they are killed by their evil uncle Durjan Singh (Amrish Puri), Durga prays to Goddess Kali to return her sons to her. Karan and Arjun are reborn but in different places and not knowing their past. When they learn about their previous life, they join forces to take revenge upon Durjan Singh. Written by Soum ff0 itra

This is the story of ultimate patience and absolute belief. Rakhee is the mother of Karan & Arjun, who are killed by the evil man Durjan Singh(Amrish Puri) but her belief in goddess Kali, allows Karan & Arjun to be born again. Karan & Arjun get born in the city, away from the village that they lived in their previous life. When Karan & Arjun grow up they don't remember anything except the feeling they know each other from somewhere. So the questions arise, will Karan & Arjun recall who they are?, Will they get back to their village to their mother who has been waiting for 20 years? and Will they take their revenge against Durjan Singh? Written by Neo

When Durga's husband speaks out against the tyrannical rule of his brother, Durjan Singh, he is mercilessly killed, and Durga and her two children, Karan and Arjun, are left destitute. Durga brings up her sons without informing them of their heritage nor of the death of their father, but they soon find out when the elder Thakur decides to invite Durga back into his household. This does not auger well with Durjan Singh, and he has the elder Thakur killed. When he finds out about Durga, he goes to end her life, but her sons spring up to defend her, only to get themselves killed. Alone, destitute more than ever, and devastated, Durga loses her mind, and prays to God to bring her sons back so that they can avenge her humiliation, and the death of their father. Seventeen years later, two youth re-enter her life, they do look like her sons, and are ready to take on Durjan Singh, but will they also meet the same fate as Karan, Arjun, their father?

一个很难接受的印度教故事背景，我竟然把它看完了，还觉得很精彩！

打斗和复仇的情节描写有创意且节奏抓人，有点像《地道战》的feel。印度电影真的很奇妙，很多看起来情节并不出彩的故事，却能被演绎的很吸引人。看起来在故事之外的演绎，包括表演节奏和每个情节的创意表达，真的是电影非常重要的部分。

顺便说，那个时候的沙沙，脸真是圆啊，活脱脱一个大苹果的脸。小萨那时还很瘦，身材真的很好，颜值超赞！